
BANANA FISH β A shounen-ai film adapted from its fifty-year old source material, Banana fish β which was completed late last year β has certainly hit its wide range of audiences with a vast spectrum of themes, and of course, an uproar of mixed feelings.
Banana Fish, despite its odd name, doesn’t have anything to do with food at all. It circles around the life of an infamous gang leader β Ash Lynx β and his queer encounter with a Japanese photographer, Okumura Eiji. There, a series of webbed events leads to the revelation of an interconnected past, as well as intricate investigations; all centring on the mysterious drug known as ‘Banana Fish’.
What first struck me when I went headfirst into this anime is it’s clear-cut and fast-paced action. It doesn’t stick to a setting too long, and instead uses that to its advantage in building up a tower-like pile of tension. Banana Fish’s setting draws us in naturally β it possesses a type of hook and feeling that simply begs you to binge it.
With concrete and well-emphasised themes, I also can’t help but feel that they went a little over the top here. Sure, I definitely enjoyed the thorough exposition of extremely delicate topics, and the continuous showcasing of humanity’s awful nature; but there was something I really couldn’t overlook, and that was it’s evident and overused drama.
It’s no excuse that even with a single episode drawing me in, I felt much more inclined to binge this series as a whole. However, despite its evenly paced start, Banana Fish spins off chaotically, squeezing in swift, action-driven narratives and excruciatingly slow emotional scenes that messed up the plot as a whole. It got really irritating after binging the first half, not to mention the utter chaos present in its later episodes.
It’s pacing all over the pace by the second cour, the constant kidnappings and hostages not only ruined the overall impact, but also presented us with a bundle of overused and old troupes. It’s simply continuous situations where the separation of the main duo would lead to a time-ticking bomb of who would be recovered first. If it wasn’t Eiji that was captured, it would be Ash’s turn to be tormented. It’s a rinse-and-repeat formula that would eventually tire you out.
Adding on to the situation at hand, Banana Fish enjoys shifting its concentration from a heartfelt film to an action-packed anime where a mystery unfolds. Don’t get me wrong, I absolutely adore the riveting emotions it presents, but the fact that the entire narrative was delayed or even pushed to being secondary really irritated me at times.
This anime could’ve incorporated both the heartbreaking feels and the compelling suspense into one major narrative, but instead, it’s broken up into two overarching ideas that takes its own form. It feels rigid and unpolished together, not to mention disconnected.
Banana Fish relishes in taking its own pace. A dark and dangerous revelation of the drug’s true nature densely packed at the beginning, the second half then diverts its attention to our main duo, with the original narrative almost forgotten and pushed to a hasty conclusion. I almost doubted its ability to completely wrap-up the entire series.
The characterisation on the other hand, felt unevenly distributed, yet well-done when closely dissected.
Ash’s backstory is not only heartbreaking, but it’s something that shapes him as a character and unveils his true emotions. It isn’t a definition of him, rather, it’s a interconnected tale that delivers a larger picture depicting his strength and personality. His development supported by his past, we get to see how far he has come and how truly broken he is inside. It’s a story of how people aren’t strong on the inside, no matter how tough they may seem. Banana Fish tells us just that.
Eiji, on the flip-side, presents us with the charm of wanting the power and initiative to help those he cares about. He’s innocent, timid and shy in the beginning, but as we began to see his growth as a character, Eiji becomes an irreplaceable part of the story that is the centre of Ash’s growth. He’s the direct opposite of Ash β strength in the heart, not on the outside.
With the beauty of Banana Fish’s carefully crafted relationships, we see how they grow and support one another. Eiji possesses a tough mind, whereas Ash exhibits his power through physical force. It’s one that isn’t meant to be, but the way they change due to each other’s influence is one of the strengths of this show.
Yut-Lung is an interesting character that reminds me of a child fixated on revenge. He’s someone that was ruined by vengeance, with too much overflowing emotions that ran with careless action. Portrayed in a way where he is more driven by anger than anything else, it brims with so much room for character development.
Sing was someone that is more of a follower than a leader. He’s flooded with a lot of moral dilemma and questions, so much that he doesn’t know who to trust anymore. Amongst the cast and second only to Ash, I’d say that he’s a character with much more inner conflict.
OVERALL, ignoring the ending which was completely uncalled for and simply there for its last attempt at tear-jerking, Banana Fish excels more on its complex characters than its actual narrative, the pacing being one of its major concerns. With more polishing and attention to larger details, this anime could’ve been so much better.
ratings =
setting & themes | 7
pacing & narrative | 5.5
characters | 8.5
overall | 7
what are your thoughts on banana fish? thank you for reading and do drop by my blog for more reviews xx
find me on =
@ani.raeviews β instagram





